My current research aims at better understanding the strategies of environmental conservation organisations in five different countries (United States, Canada, United Kingdom, Germany and Switzerland). Focusing on land, considered as a scarce resource, this research project postulates that the sustainable management of resources must be understood not only as resulting from public policies, but also from the formal property rights. The interest of highlighting these two mechanisms of regulation has to do with the fact that their interaction is far from being harmonious.
More specifically, this project aims at analyzing comparatively the landowner strategies used by private or para-public actors in charge of nature conservation and environment management in five countries, in order to highlight their specificities and similarities. By “landowner strategy” I refer to the choices made by these actors to have recourse to a given legal instrument to accomplish their legal or statutory mission. Following questions will be examined: (1) To what extent do nature conservation and environment management organizations use land property and/or political strategies to accomplish their legal or statutory mission? (2) How does the national conception of land property, revealed in concrete terms in the way that the regulative activity of the State is able to constrain property rights, contribute to explain the strategies followed by environmental management organizations? (3) How does the characteristics of the nature conservation organizations (legal form, structure, decision-making procedures, extent of land owned, etc.) and their political resources (political support, money, time, consensus, etc.) influence their strategies? (4) Which preliminary link is it possible to establish between the strategies of nature conservation organizations and the social, economic and ecologic sustainability of their uses of the resource land?
The methods used stem from public policy analysis. As a direct product of legislative activities of parliaments, public policies benefit from a great legitimacy. Thus their analysis is a reliable method to understand the characteristics of land tenure laws of a given country. Detailed case studies of the different environmental management organisms will be carried out in order to analyze how legislation is actually implemented in practice and how the concerned actors mobilize such or such legal disposition to defend their interests. During this research, I will be based in the team of prof. Lynn Huntsinger.